Three Letters
Who bears a cargo loss under FOB, FCA, CIF or DAP? Understand Incoterms® 2020 risk transfer, insurance and cargo claims, plus the Incoterms® 2030 revision now under way.

At 3 a.m. on a June morning in 2025, the crew of the car carrier Morning Midas abandoned ship in the North Pacific.
Smoke had been spotted on a deck packed with electric vehicles, roughly 300 miles south of Adak, Alaska. The CO₂ suppression system couldn’t hold it. All 22 seafarers were rescued by a passing ship — but the fire kept burning for weeks, and the vessel, with around 3,000 vehicles aboard, eventually sank to the bottom of the ocean. The estimated loss: around US$560 million.
The Morning Midas was not a freak event. It was the latest in a steady drumbeat of catastrophic fires that share a common, unglamorous root cause — dangerous goods that were never properly declared, packed or stowed. And for anyone who ships, insures or handles cargo, this is the risk that quietly underwrites almost everything else.
| The scale of the problem (the numbers that should worry every shipper) |
|
|
|
|
HOW MISDECLARATION ACTUALLY HAPPENS
Declaring cargo as dangerous costs money. It demands special packaging, documentation, restricted stowage and higher freight rates. So the temptation is obvious: a shipper labels fireworks as “toys,” lithium-ion batteries as “computer parts,” or self-heating charcoal under a vague commercial name — and a hazard walks onto the ship disguised as something harmless.
But — and this matters for how claims play out — misdeclaration is not always fraud. A large share of it is simple ignorance: manufacturers who don’t realise their product meets the criteria for a dangerous good, or logistics staff who use a marketing name instead of the correct Proper Shipping Name. Whether deliberate or innocent, the physics inside a sealed steel box are the same. The hazard is loaded, stowed next to incompatible cargo or near a heat source, and nobody on board knows it’s there until it ignites.
“A container is a sealed black box. Once the doors are shut, the crew is trusting a piece of paper — and the paper is wrong more often than the industry would like.”
LITHIUM-ION BATTERIES AND THE EV BOOM
If misdeclaration is the old problem, lithium-ion batteries are the accelerant pouring onto it. The world’s appetite for batteries is exploding — global demand is projected to rise from roughly 700 GWh in 2022 to around 4.7 TWh by 2030. Every one of those cells, and every electric vehicle built around them, has to move somewhere, and a great deal of it moves by sea.
Lithium-ion fires are uniquely nasty at sea. They can burn at extreme temperatures, vent toxic gas, and reignite after appearing to be extinguished — a phenomenon known as thermal runaway. Conventional firefighting often can’t reach or cool them, which is why the US Coast Guard chose simply to let the Morning Midas burn out rather than risk lives. The Felicity Ace (2022) and Fremantle Highway (2023) followed similar arcs: car carriers, EVs aboard, days of fire, enormous losses.
The risk is now serious enough that major carriers have started refusing EVs outright. Following the Morning Midas loss, US lines Matson and Alaska Marine Lines both suspended electric-vehicle and plug-in-hybrid shipments, citing the inability to contain a lithium-ion fire at sea. When carriers begin turning away cargo, the commercial ripple — and the contractual and insurance questions — reaches every shipper in the chain.
THE QUIET MENACE: CHARCOAL, AND WHY 2026 CHANGES EVERYTHING
Not every fire risk is high-tech. One of the most persistent culprits is utterly mundane: charcoal. As a self-heating substance, charcoal can spontaneously combust in a hot container, and it has been linked to dozens of container fires over the past decade.
For years it slipped through a loophole — exemption tests and vague trade names like “bamboo charcoal” or “shisha tablets” let it travel as ordinary, non-dangerous cargo.
Under IMDG Code Amendment 42-24, mandatory worldwide from 1 January 2026, charcoal must always be declared and carried as dangerous goods— no more exemptions. The rules are strict and specific: a minimum 14-day weathering period before packing, cargo no hotter than 40°C on packing day, a 30 cm headspace in the container, and full documentation. Major carriers including Maersk and Hapag-Lloyd jumped early, demanding compliance through 2025.
Charcoal is just the headline. The same 2026 IMDG edition also tightens the rules around lithium-ion batteries and electric vehicles, narrowing the exemptions that previously let many EVs travel as non-dangerous goods.
WHEN THE BOX CATCHES FIRE: THE CLAIMS AFTERMATH
This is where a cargo fire stops being a safety story and becomes a claims story — and it’s rarely simple. A single misdeclared container can trigger a cascade that touches every party on the vessel:
WHAT CARGO INTERESTS SHOULD TAKE FROM THIS
| Cargo lost or damaged in a fire at sea? |
|
|
| Sources & Further Reading |
|
|
|
|
|
| This article is provided for general information and does not constitute legal or claims advice. |
HOW COLLYERS CAN HELP
Collyers is a specialist third-party administrator handling cargo, freight, and liability claims across road, sea, air, and warehouse worldwide. If you are a cargo owner, freight forwarder, broker, or insurer affected by port disruption, carrier liability disputes, or vessel incidents, our team can help you navigate the claims process. Whether you need to understand your recovery options under the applicable convention, coordinate a survey, pursue a subrogated recovery, or simply want to know where you stand – contact us.
Collyers Industry Alerts – providing practical insights into developments affecting global cargo claims and freight liability risk.
Who bears a cargo loss under FOB, FCA, CIF or DAP? Understand Incoterms® 2020 risk transfer, insurance and cargo claims, plus the Incoterms® 2030 revision now under way.
Reefer and cold chain cargo failures account for around 30% of container-vessel cargo claims. Why pharma and food losses are uniquely complex, the five ways cold chains break, and how to build a claim that survives. From Collyers.
Understand CMR road freight claims, including the 7-day concealed damage rule, 8.33 SDR/kg liability limit, 21-day delay notice and one-year time bar. Practical guidance from Collyers.
