Industry Alerts

A UK buyer purchases a container of specialised machinery from a supplier in Shenzhen. The sale contract says, in a single line that nobody re-read after it was drafted: “FOB Shenzhen, Incoterms® 2020.” Four weeks later, after the goods have been loaded on board the nominated vessel, a casualty occurs and General Average is declared. The buyer receives a substantial GA security demand and calls the seller, assuming it remains the seller’s transit risk. Under FOB, however, risk normally transfers when the goods are on board the vessel at the named port of shipment. Those three letters have materially changed the buyer’s position.

That is the Incoterms trap. The sale contract’s shortest clause — three letters, often buried in a purchase order most people never read — silently decides who bears the risk of transit damage, who files the claim, who posts the General Average bond, who absorbs the delay, and who argues with the insurer. Get it wrong and the claim can be legally watertight and commercially unwinnable — by the party who thought they had the loss.

Incoterms is one of the highest-frequency, highest-consequence features of international cargo trade — and one of the most consistently misunderstood. Here’s what every buyer, seller, forwarder and insurer in 2026 needs to have straight.

Incoterms in 60 seconds — the essentials

  • Incoterms are the international commercial terms published by the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) — the global shorthand for who does what in a sale of goods.
  • Current version: Current edition: Incoterms® 2020. The ICC has begun the formal revision process for Incoterms® 2030, with publication currently planned for late 2029. Parties may still incorporate an earlier edition into their contract where that edition is clearly specified.
  • Each rule allocates FIVE things between seller and buyer: (1) delivery, (2) risk of loss or damage, (3) cost, (4) carriage arrangements, (5) insurance (for CIP and CIF only).
  • The two most important moments are: when risk passes, and when cost responsibility ends. These are not always the same point.
  • Four rules are sea-only (FAS, FOB, CFR, CIF). Seven are multimodal (EXW, FCA, CPT, CIP, DAP, DPU, DDP).
  • CIP changed significantly under Incoterms® 2020: the default insurance requirement moved to the broader Institute Cargo Clauses (A), or similar cover, subject to the policy’s terms and exclusions. The parties remain free to agree a different level of cover.

Source: International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) — Incoterms® 2020.

WHY INCOTERMS ARE A CARGO CLAIMS ISSUE, NOT JUST A SALES ISSUE
Incoterms live on the sale contract between buyer and seller. The contract of carriage — bill of lading, air waybill, CMR note — is a separate instrument altogether. But the two interact in exactly one critical place: the moment transit risk changes hands. That moment is set by the Incoterm, and it decides a lot:

  • Who has the right to claim. Who bears the commercial loss. The Incoterm is an important starting point for determining whether the buyer or seller bore transit risk when the loss occurred. The separate question of who has rights against a carrier or insurer will also depend on the carriage contract, insurance arrangements and applicable law.
  • Who has the insurable interest. Who should have the relevant cargo cover. The Incoterm helps identify where transit risk sits between buyer and seller, but the insurance position should always be checked against the actual policy and the party’s legal or economic interest in the goods. Misalignment between risk transfer and insurance arrangements is a common source of coverage disputes.
  • Who bears General Average. GA is proportional to the saved property. Who may ultimately bear General Average exposure. Incoterms can materially affect the allocation of risk between buyer and seller, but GA security and contribution obligations also depend on the property interests, carriage documents, insurance arrangements and circumstances of the casualty.
  • Who owns delay exposure. Cost responsibility and risk responsibility can split under some Incoterms. One party pays the freight, another bears the delay. That gap is where disputes thrive.
  • Who bears demurrage, detention and port costs. Who may bear demurrage, detention and port costs. Incoterms allocate a range of costs between buyer and seller, but particular demurrage, detention and terminal charges may also depend on the carriage contract, terminal terms and the circumstances in which the charge arose.

“Incoterms are the three letters that decide whether your cargo claim is yours to bring, or the counterparty’s to ignore.”

THE THREE TRAPS THAT KEEP CATCHING SHIPPERS OUT
From the claims desk, the same three Incoterms errors recur:

  • Trap 1 — Using FOB on container shipments Using FOB where FCA better matches container operations. Under FOB, delivery and risk transfer occur when the goods are on board the nominated vessel. But containerised goods are commonly handed to the carrier at a terminal before that point, leaving the seller without physical control even though it may still bear the transit risk under FOB. The ICC therefore recommends considering FCA where goods are handed to a carrier at a container terminal before being loaded on board the vessel.
  • Trap 2 — Mixing or omitting Incoterms editions. Incoterms® 2020 is the current edition, but parties may contract using earlier editions. Writing only “DDP London, Incoterms” without specifying an edition creates unnecessary ambiguity. The differences can matter: under Incoterms® 2020, for example, the default insurance requirement under CIP moved from the more limited Institute Cargo Clauses (C) level used in the 2010 rules to the broader Institute Cargo Clauses (A) level. Always state the chosen rule, named place or port and edition clearly.
  • Trap 3 — Treating “risk” and “cost” as the same point. Several Incoterms split risk and cost at different points in the journey. For example, under CIF the seller’s cost responsibility extends to the destination port but risk passes to the buyer at the loading port. A buyer assuming they are “covered until destination” because the seller is paying freight is making a dangerous assumption.

THE PROPOSED UPCOMING CHANGE: INCOTERMS 2030
The ICC has begun work on the next revision of the Incoterms® rules, with publication currently targeted for late 2029. During 2026, national ICC committees and users are being consulted on how Incoterms® 2020 operates in practice and where clarification or development may be needed.

Topics being discussed through the consultation process include digitalisation of trade documentation, the realities of containerised and multimodal transport, compliance requirements and other changes in international trade. The eventual wording is not yet settled, and businesses should be cautious about treating predictions about Incoterms® 2030 as confirmed changes.

For contracts being written today, Incoterms® 2020 remains the current edition. The practical control is simple: specify the rule, the named place or port and the edition clearly for example, “FCA Birmingham, Incoterms® 2020” rather than simply “FCA Birmingham.” A future edition will not automatically rewrite the wording the parties agreed in an existing contract.

CHOOSING THE RIGHT INCOTERM — A PRACTICAL FRAMEWORK
No single Incoterm is “best.” The right choice depends on who controls the carrier, who holds the better cargo cover, who has the local relationships at origin and destination, and where risk is cheapest to carry. Three principles that cut through the complexity:

  • Match the Incoterm to the mode. Sea-only rules (FOB, FAS, CFR, CIF) for break-bulk and non-containerised sea cargo. Multimodal rules (FCA, CPT, CIP, DAP, DPU, DDP, EXW) for containers, air, road, rail and intermodal — which is almost everything in 2026.
  • Match the Incoterm to who controls the risk. Risk should sit with the party best placed to prevent, insure or recover against it. A buyer with no visibility into the exporter’s choice of carrier is a poor risk-bearer for the on-carriage leg.
  • Match the Incoterm to the cover. Cargo insurance should respond to the party actually bearing the risk. Where buyer and seller each think the other is insuring the voyage, the result is often a claim where neither cover responds and the loss falls between the stools.

WHAT TO DO WHEN A CLAIM LANDS
When cargo goes wrong, one of the first commercial questions should be: who bore the risk when the loss occurred? Check the agreed Incoterm, named place or port, the edition incorporated into the contract and the known point of loss before assuming whether the buyer or seller bears the transit risk.

  • Check the Incoterm first. Before working out what happened, work out who had risk when it happened. The sale contract and the moment of loss together decide who has standing to claim.
  • Confirm the Incoterms version. CIF 2000, CIF 2010 and CIF 2020 are all legally valid. They are not identical. The version decides the fine detail.
  • Map the moment of loss onto the risk-transfer point. A loss on board the vessel after sailing from Shanghai, under FOB Shanghai, is the buyer’s. Under DAP London it is the seller’s. Under CIF London the seller paid for freight and insurance — but risk still passed in Shanghai.
  • Check whose insurance should respond. The policy of the party at risk at the moment of loss. If no one at risk is insured, the claim becomes a conversation with the carrier under the applicable convention — subject to all the package limitation and time bar issues we have written about elsewhere.
  • Preserve the sale contract paperwork alongside the carriage paperwork. Purchase order, sale contract, commercial invoice. All three set out the Incoterms position — and inconsistencies between them are themselves a source of dispute.

WHERE COLLYERS COMES IN
Incoterms sit at the hinge between the commercial sale and the carriage — which is exactly where cargo claims live. Working out whose claim this actually is, under which rule set, at what moment, is one of the first things a specialist claims adjuster does when a loss notification arrives. Done well, it short-circuits months of parallel disputes between parties who all thought the loss was somebody else’s. Done badly, it means a valid claim is brought by the wrong party and quietly fails.

The bottom line: the Incoterm on the sale contract is the three-letter clause that decides more cargo claims than almost anything else. Reading it carefully, specifying it precisely, and aligning insurance to it is the cheapest control any cargo buyer or seller can put in place.

Cargo claim where the Incoterm is contested?
The right party to claim, the right insurer to respond, and the right moment of risk transfer are the opening questions in every well-run cargo claim.

Collyers handles marine cargo, air freight and road freight liability claims from first notification through to recovery. Talk to our claims team or get in touch directly.

Collyers Industry Alerts – providing practical insights into developments affecting global cargo claims and freight liability risk.

Industry Alerts

Three Degrees From Disaster

Reefer and cold chain cargo failures account for around 30% of container-vessel cargo claims. Why pharma and food losses are uniquely complex, the five ways cold chains break, and how to build a claim that survives. From Collyers.

Read more
Industry Alerts

The Rust Beneath the Vessel

Global shipping losses are at a record low — but vessels aged 20+ years now cause more than half of all incidents. Why an ageing fleet is 2026’s quietest cargo claims risk, and what shippers should do. From Collyers.

Read more